Skip to content
Aback Launch
Guides9 min read

How to Compare Websites for SEO: A Side by Side Competitor Analysis (With a Worksheet)

How to compare two websites for SEO: authority, referring domains, on-page basics, speed, content coverage and technical health, with a side by side worksheet and what to do with each gap.

Devvrat Hans

Founder

November 19, 2026
How to Compare Websites for SEO: A Side by Side Competitor Analysis (With a Worksheet)

To compare websites for SEO, put your site next to the competitor that outranks you and compare six things: domain authority, referring domains, on-page basics, page speed, content coverage and technical health. The gaps tell you why they rank above you and what to fix first. The quickest start is to paste your page and theirs into our free SEO compare tool, which puts the on-page basics side by side, then check both domains' authority with the domain rating checker.

A website SEO comparison is not about copying a competitor. It is about finding out which of the usual reasons explains the gap between you and them, so you spend the next month on the right thing. A new startup that is behind on authority needs links, not more blog posts. One that is behind on content needs pages, not links. The comparison tells you which.

Pick the right competitor and the right pages

The competitor that matters for SEO is not always your business rival. It is whoever ranks above you for the searches you want. Before you compare two websites for SEO:

  1. Choose one or two target keywords you want to rank for, the ones closest to buying.
  2. Search them in a private window and note the sites in the top five. Those are your SEO competitors for that keyword, even if one is a blog or a directory.
  3. Pick the specific ranking page, not just the domain. Google ranks pages. Compare their ranking page with the page of yours that should rank for the same search.
  4. Prefer a beatable competitor. If the top five are all huge brands, compare yourself with the smallest site in the top ten. That is the one whose position you can realistically take.

The six things to compare

1. Domain authority

Authority scores estimate how strong a site's backlink profile is. The best known is Ahrefs' Domain Rating (DR), from 0 to 100. It is a third-party estimate, not a Google number, but it is a fair shorthand for "how many good sites link here". DR is logarithmic: going from 20 to 30 takes far more links than going from 0 to 10, so a 10 point gap at the top of the scale is much bigger than one at the bottom.

The free domain rating checker shows a domain's Ahrefs DR along with its new DR4 score, its Tranco popularity rank, domain age, and HTTPS and email setup. To compare several competitors at once, the bulk domain authority checker takes up to 20 domains and puts them in one sortable table. Ahrefs makes DR4 its default rating on December 1, 2026, so some scores will move; our DR4 study shows how much.

2. Referring domains

A referring domain is a distinct website that links to you. It is a better comparison than raw backlink counts, because one site linking from every page of its footer can produce thousands of backlinks and still be one referring domain. Ahrefs' free backlink checker shows a site's backlink and linking website counts and a sample of its strongest links, which is enough for a comparison. Look at the sample, not only the count: where do their links come from? Launch directories, review sites, guest posts, press, integrations pages? That is your link building list. Our guide to referring domains vs backlinks explains why the distinct sites matter more.

3. On-page basics

This is where a side by side comparison of the two pages is most useful. Our SEO compare tool audits both URLs and highlights the better value in each row:

  • The overall on-page SEO score from our checker
  • Title length and description length
  • H1 count and total headings
  • Word count
  • Images and images missing alt text
  • Internal and external links
  • Structured data types found
  • Server response time and HTML size

What it does not do: it compares two pages, not two whole sites, and it does not count backlinks, which need a link index. Use it for the page pair you chose above, then repeat with other pairs.

Read the rows as clues, not scores. Word count is not a ranking factor by itself, but if their page has 2,500 words and yours 600, they probably answer questions yours skips. More headings usually means more subtopics covered. Schema types you lack (FAQPage, Product, SoftwareApplication, HowTo) show what they mark up. More internal links means their site points to that page harder than yours does.

4. Page speed

Speed rarely explains a big ranking gap on its own, but a page that takes several seconds to load loses both visitors and the tie-break against a similar page. Run both URLs through the free page speed checker, which measures server response time, page weight, compression, caching and render-blocking files, and links to PageSpeed Insights for a full Lighthouse run.

Google's Core Web Vitals thresholds are the reference: Largest Contentful Paint under 2.5 seconds, Interaction to Next Paint under 200 milliseconds and Cumulative Layout Shift under 0.1. If both sites pass, speed is not your problem; move on.

5. Content coverage

Content coverage is how much of the topic each site covers. A competitor with forty pages about your subject will rank for hundreds of searches you do not appear for, and Google learns to trust their site on the topic (what SEOs call topical authority).

  • Count their pages by section. The free sitemap link counter counts every URL in a sitemap, per child sitemap and per section, so you can see they have 120 blog posts and 30 integration pages while you have 8 and 0.
  • List their topics. Skim the titles of their blog and resource pages. Which subtopics do they cover that you do not? Those are your content gaps.
  • Note their page types. Comparison pages, alternatives pages, templates, free tools, integration pages and glossaries each rank for a different kind of search.

6. Technical health

Technical problems are the cheapest gaps to close, and sometimes the whole explanation. Check both sites for:

  • Crawlability: robots.txt does not block important pages. A robots.txt tester shows whether Googlebot may fetch a URL and which rule decides.
  • Indexability: no stray noindex on pages that should rank (see our noindex tag guide).
  • A valid sitemap listing the pages that should be indexed.
  • HTTPS everywhere, one canonical version of each URL, and no redirect chains.
  • Server-rendered content. If your product pages only show text after JavaScript runs and theirs are static HTML, they are easier for every crawler to read.

The side by side worksheet

Fill this in for your site and one competitor. The last column tells you whether a gap is likely to matter.

MetricWhere to checkYouCompetitorGap matters when
Domain Rating (and DR4)Domain rating checkerThey are 15+ points ahead
Referring domainsAhrefs' free backlink checkerThey have several times more
Links to the ranking pageAhrefs' free backlink checker (page URL)Their page has links and yours has none
On-page SEO scoreSEO compare toolYou have failed checks they do not
Words and headingsSEO compare toolThey cover subtopics you skip
Structured dataSEO compare toolThey have a type that earns a rich result
Internal links to the pageSEO compare tool, site crawlTheir page is linked from many of their pages
Server response and page weightPage speed checkerYours fails Core Web Vitals and theirs passes
Pages on the topicSitemap link counter, their blogThey have many more on your topic
Crawl and index healthrobots.txt tester, SEO checkerAny blocked or noindexed key page

What to do with the gaps

Do not try to close every gap at once. Work in this order, because each step makes the next one count for more.

  1. Fix technical blockers first. A noindex, a robots.txt block or a broken canonical will cancel everything else. These take minutes.
  2. Close the on-page gaps on the page pair. Rewrite the title to lead with the keyword, cover the subtopics the competitor covers (and one or two they missed), add the schema type that fits, fix missing alt text. Our on-page SEO checklist covers each item.
  3. Point your own site at the page. Add internal links from related pages with descriptive anchors. This is free authority you already own.
  4. Fill the content gaps one cluster at a time, starting with subtopics closest to your product.
  5. Close the authority gap with real links. For a new startup the first referring domains usually come from launch platforms and directories, then from content and tools other sites cite.

If the competitor is 40 DR points ahead with ten times the referring domains, accept that you will not beat them on that keyword this quarter. Use the free keyword difficulty estimator to find related, longer searches where the sites ranking are closer to your own authority, and win those first.

How to compare website ranking

"Compare website ranking" can mean two things, and they need different tools.

  • Who ranks higher for a keyword: search it in a private window, signed out, and note both positions. Results vary by location and device, so treat any single check as approximate. For your own site, Google Search Console's Performance report gives your average position for every query, which is far more reliable than spot checks.
  • Which site ranks for more overall: only paid SEO suites estimate a competitor's total keywords and traffic, from their own crawls. Their numbers are estimates and can be far off for small sites. For a free proxy, compare authority, referring domains and the number of pages on the topic, which together explain most of the difference.

Popularity ranks, like the Tranco rank our domain checker shows, compare overall site popularity from several traffic sources. They are useful for big sites; most small startups are not in the top million and show no rank at all, which is normal.

Repeat it every quarter

A competitor SEO analysis is a snapshot. Save your worksheet, and repeat the comparison every three months, or after you ship a big change. The trend matters more than any one number: if your referring domains and topic pages are growing faster than theirs, the ranking gap will follow.

FAQ

How do I compare two websites for SEO?

Pick the competitor that outranks you for a keyword you want, then compare domain authority, referring domains, the on-page basics of the two ranking pages, page speed, how many pages each site has on the topic and technical health. A side by side tool covers the on-page part in seconds; authority and links need a domain checker.

Is there a free SEO website comparison tool?

Yes. Our SEO compare tool audits two pages side by side (titles, descriptions, headings, word count, images and alt text, links, structured data, response time and HTML size) and highlights the better value in each row. For authority, the domain rating checker and the bulk checker compare Ahrefs DR for free.

How can I see where a competitor ranks?

For a single keyword, search it signed out in a private window and note their position. For a full list of their keywords, you need a paid SEO suite, and its numbers are estimates. For your own site, Google Search Console shows real average positions for every query.

What matters most when comparing websites for SEO?

For most young sites, the biggest gaps are referring domains and content coverage, and technical blockers are the quickest fixes. Speed and small on-page differences rarely explain a big ranking gap on their own, but they decide close calls between similar pages.

Does a higher Domain Rating always mean better rankings?

No. DR is a third-party estimate of link strength, and Google does not use it. A site with lower DR often outranks a stronger one with a page that answers the search better, especially for specific, longer searches.

Run your first comparison

Take the keyword you most want to rank for, find the page above you, and paste both URLs into the free SEO compare tool. Then check both domains in the domain rating checker and fill in the worksheet. Twenty minutes later you will know whether your next month is about links, content or fixes.

Written by

Devvrat Hans

Founder

Share
Newsletter
Get the Monday launch email
The week's new launches and winners, in one short email.

By subscribing, you agree to get our newsletter by email. Unsubscribe any time in one click. See our Privacy policy and Terms.

Launch your startup on Aback Launch

Get a launch page that search engines and AI assistants can read, a place in the weekly launch list, and a review by a real person. Free to join.